Founding editor of the *Christian Standard* (1866), Errett became a leading voice of moderate Disciples. He popularized the motto "Christians only, not the only Christians," emphasizing unity, cooperation, evangelism, and a non‑sectarian identity for the movement.
Born in New York and converted through Walter Scott's evangelistic preaching, Errett became one of the most influential leaders of the Disciples of Christ in the late 19th century. His *Christian Standard* offered a progressive alternative to more conservative journals like the *Gospel Advocate*, advocating for organized cooperation, missionary societies, and an irenic spirit in dealing with differences.
Errett believed the Restoration plea should be a unifying force, not a sectarian badge. He championed the slogan "Christians only, not the only Christians," insisting that the movement should recognize all who confess Christ while maintaining its distinctive commitment to New Testament Christianity. He defended believer's baptism and weekly communion but resisted making every practice a test of fellowship. His moderate, generous approach helped shape the Disciples of Christ's cooperative ethos, though it also contributed to tensions with more conservative leaders who viewed cooperation and innovations as departures from apostolic simplicity.
Relationships
-
Converted by: Walter Scott
Scott's preaching brought Errett into the Restoration movement. -
Succeeded: Alexander Campbell
Errett carried forward Campbell's vision of cooperative unity after Campbell's death. -
Converted by: Walter Scott
Scott's preaching brought Errett into the movement.
Selected Quotes
“Christians only, not the only Christians—this is our plea, and it must be spoken in humility, not arrogance.”
“Our aim is not to build a party, but to unite the people of God on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Christ Jesus himself being the chief cornerstone.”
“Unity does not require uniformity. We can agree on essentials while allowing liberty in opinions.”